Engineering blueprints backgroundEngineering blueprints background
Back to Blog
Home building insurance claims4 min read

What if I disagree with the insurance assessment report?

A focused way to question the facts and reasoning without writing your own diagnosis

Write to the insurer with the exact passage you disagree with, why you dispute it and any records that could change it. An incorrect room name, a missed invoice and a disputed cause need different responses. Ask how the insurer has used the report, whether it has made a claim decision and who makes that decision.

To discuss an engineering review of existing reports and documents, explore our desktop engineering reviews. An article cannot determine the cause or appropriate solution for an individual property.

Steps for questioning an insurance assessment report.
Steps for questioning an insurance assessment report.
Steps for questioning an insurance assessment report.

Identify the kind of disagreement

Keep the date and version of the report, including any revisions. Separate what the assessor saw, what others told them and what they concluded.

The issueWhat to identifyA useful request
A factual errorThe wrong location, date, material or recorded account.Identify the passage, give the correction and attach the record that supports it.
Missing evidenceA relevant photograph, invoice, earlier report or part of the property that appears unaddressed.Ask whether it was reviewed and whether it changes the assessment.
Technical reasoningA conclusion whose observations, assumptions or explanation you cannot follow.Ask the author to explain the evidence and reasoning, including any relevant competing explanation.
Policy applicationThe insurer's use of a policy term to accept or exclude some damage.Ask the insurer which wording and findings it relied on, and which parts of the loss its decision covers.

Use a small correction request

Illustrative wording for a factual correction:

The report refers to an earlier kitchen leak, but the attached repair invoice relates to the bathroom. Please check the passage I have identified, confirm whether the history has been attributed to the wrong room and let me know if this affects any finding or decision.

Use your own records and say if a date is uncertain. An earlier photograph may establish the condition of surfaces visible at that time, but it cannot show concealed damage.

When the explanation is wear or pre existing damage

Ask what condition the assessor observed, where it was found and how it relates to the damage in the claim. If the report mentions an earlier defect, ask whether the conclusion concerns that defect, later damage or both. Ask the insurer separately how it links those findings to the policy wording it relies on.

You do not need to propose another cause to ask for clarification. An old maintenance record may not resolve questions about a later event either. Keep the technical explanation separate from the insurer's policy response.

What to do with the response

  • Check whether the reply addresses the passage and evidence you identified, rather than repeating the original conclusion.
  • Ask whether the author has issued a correction, an addendum or an explanation that leaves the original view unchanged. Keep the dated versions together.
  • If a technical question remains, describe it narrowly before seeking advice from an appropriately qualified specialist. Ask about the proposed work, fees and who will pay before commissioning it; insurer funding is not assured.

If the insurer has declined or partly accepted the claim, respond to that decision as well as any report error. If your concern remains unresolved, explain the issue and the response you want through the insurer's complaint process; you need not wait until you can produce a replacement expert report.